How big a Standing Rib Roast?

OldMayfield

Active member
Joined
Jun 18, 2020
Messages
117
Media
14
Reaction score
82
Location
Southeast USA
Grill
Pro 780
I'm cooking a standing rib roast on Christmas Day for 11. How many ribs should I buy? Last year we had 8, I can't remember if I bought 4 or 5 ribs, but we had a boatload of leftover meat.

It came out awesome by the way.
 
Last year we had 8, I can't remember if I bought 4 or 5 ribs, but we had a boatload of leftover meat.
Well, you were on this forum before last Christmas, did you POST you cook then? That'll tell ya

► Well i checked your history, you didn't post it
If you are only adding 3 more peeps, I'd go with the 5 since you had a "boatload" left over
 
It is always difficult to judge how much to cook for a family gathering. If you are cooking steaks and potatoes, you can figure on 8-12 ounces per person unless you have a big steak eater who likes 16 ounce steaks. However, with a holiday feast, you tend to have multiple salads, side dishes and desserts. Thus, meat is often served in smaller portions 3-6 ounces. That is likely why you ended up with leftovers last year.

When you purchase a standing rib roast (aka prime rib), the purchase includes the weight of the bone and fat. That represents about 15% of the overall weight of the roast. If you are cooking for 8 and want to allow 8 ounces per person, you will need 64 ounces of meat (4 pounds). However, to get that amount of meat, you will need about 5 pounds of roast. That would be a 3-bone roast. However, if you are cutting the roast into steaks rather than slices, you will need more. Based on your experience last year, you might want to consider a 4 bone roast. That should allow a little more than 8 ounces of meat for hungry guests and still allow for some leftovers for prime rib sandwiches.

My wife's greatest fear is running short of food for any occasion. Thus, always cook more than you expect to consume. There were only two of us for Thanksgiving, but I cooked a 13 pound turkey. We had lots of leftovers. the breast was used for meals and sandwiches and the remainder went into a large pot of stew that was frozen into portions that will provide hearty meals this winter.
 
Typically I would say figure 1 pound per person. By the time you lose the bones, the trim, etc. you should be close. However, some parties we have there is a ton of food and everyone is full before the meal is served. Some times we have a gathering and it is basically the meal without a lot of "appetizers" so more of the meat is eaten.
 
I think the rule of thumb is 2 people per bone. But you can obviously move that up/down as you feel you need. Ask the butcher.
-PH
 
GOOD LUCK !!! 5 is what I thought, so hope it works out for you!!!
 
Well I picked it up today and it turns out 5 ribs is 12.4 lbs!!!! It will be great, but we'll be eating leftovers until Easter :D.

NP, in fact the bigger issue is all the "eaters" making it down here through the storm. @Slimpicker you're right, I should have made notes last year, this year I will.

Merry Christmas everyone! Anyone in the Venice, FL area hankering for prime rib, stop by!
 
The roast came out incredible!! One of the best Traeger cookings I’ve done.

The 5 rib/12.4# roast hit 130F in 3.5 hours at 300F (including initial 30 minutes at 500F). This included about 15 - 20 minutes where I used my handheld probe to ensure the middle of the roast hit 130F; it was about 10F lower than the Traeger probe.

Based on internet searches I expected more like 6 hours, so I covered it in foil and placed it in the cooler for a couple hours. It was wonderful. Done just right, medium edges, medium rare middle.

Not too many leftovers (only one rib leftover), and we did have one no-show, so for 11 this was probably the right size.

I used a homemade rub of salt, pepper, garlic and onion powders, rosemary and thyme.

Thanks for everyone’s help with this meal.
 
Back
Top