Having to cook a Tri Tip on a gas grill

midwest

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2021
Messages
302
Media
2
Reaction score
261
Location
Indiana
Grill
Traeger 780
I did a reverse sear tri tip for my parents a while back. Traeger set at 225 until it got to 125 then a quick sear on by Black Stone grill. My parents live out of town and they are wanting me to recreate it (the best I can on their gas grill). I was thinking of doing it with the grill on low and using a smoke tube until it gets to 125 and then cranking up the grill to seer. I know it won't be the same but do you think it can have a decent result doing it this way? Any other ideas? I know I am over thinking it but I haven't used a gas grill since I got my Traeger and now I have this thought that I'm going to get a horrible result going back to gas.
 
I just did my first tri tip ever on the Traeger and it came out great. But that's not what you want to hear LOL.

I don't think you're overthinking it; I would be in the same quandary. We pride ourselves on our cooks and want to be able to deliver great results. I think your plan is a good one, but have you thought of doing the "low and slow" part in the oven and then to the grill for the sear? Upside is that gas grills are notoriously bad at keeping a low temp for a long time. Downside is that I doubt you could use a smoke tube in your parents' oven LOL. I think with a good rub the oven method will turn out quite well regardless. Let us know what you end up doing, and the results!
 
I found out my parents do a have a small masterbuilt electric smoker, the type that look like a small dorm fridge. I haven't used one of those before and am wandering it that would be the better option then the gas grill. I am just trying to replicate the traeger results. For the crowd I am cooking for I don't want too much smoke, just similar to what I got at home.....
 
What kind of gas grill do they have?
 
Great. I've cooked a few tri tips on weber gassers as friends and family have them. This is a little long so here is the summary:

1. find the cool indirect spot
2. smoke tube burning over the one lit burner
3. cook indirect until 120F internal, Pull and wrap with foil while heating for sear
4. cut tri tip along the seam
5. Sear , rest, carve across the grain enjoy.



The key is finding the cool spot of the grill when setup for indirect heat. It is different on different grills and depending on the condition of the burners. Most weber gassers are 3 burner grills

Some weber gas grills have controls on the side and the burners go left to right, and the coolest indirect location is to use only the front burner, and cook on the right side rear. The left side has a tube called a crossover tube that carries the flame to light the middle and rear burners, and this makes the left side a little hotter.

Some weber grills have controls on the front and the burners go front to back. The coolest indirect location is to use only one outer burner and put the meat on the other side leaving the center burner off.

< if your parent's keep up on grill maintenance, this section can be skipped, but, ... >
What I would do for a grill that is not mine is give it a good cleaning. remove the grates, remove the flavorizer bar, scrape down any grease into the bottom pan, then remove the bottom pan and scrape it all into a trash can. Re install the bottom pan, and light the grill with the flav bars and grates not yet put back in. This will let you inspect the burners are all even. If so you are set. If not there could be two things to look for, a clogged burner or a cracked burner. a clogged burner might just need a good cleaning with a stainless steel brush. A cracked burner should be replaced but if you don't have time you can avoid it for the indirect cooking and use the hot spot for searing.

After you've inspected and cleaned the burners, shut it off, replace the flav bars and the grates, fire it up and get it hot for a clean off. You'll also see how quick it gets up to temp when it gets to searing time.

then I'd shut it off, let it cool down and get ready for the indirect cook. ( note you can skip all this if you parents are on top of their grill cleaning and maint) I recently cleaned my Mom's for her and it was needed.
< end of cleaning section >


When it gets to cooking time, I think you'll find one burner is more than enough for low temp indirect cooking and I'd use a smoke tube. Put the burning part of the smoke tube over the lit burner, install an indirect meat probe and smoke/cook on the cool spot until internal temp is 120F to 125F. I then pull the meat, wrap it in foil while heating the grill on high. I'd try to get the grill to at least 450F for searing. Some will easily go to 650F. If the grill has a "searing station" use that burner too.

When I reverse sear tri tip, I cut it in half along the seam. This leaves me with a larger part, and a thinner part. The larger part often needs a bit more of a sear to get it to serving temp, and having the pieces separate lets me control the done-ness separately. It also lets' me sear the cut section first.

Also, some like the tri tip done more rare or med rare and with two pieces I can sear half longer and harder and get one to Medium while leaving the other half rare.

Good luck !

I'll try to post a pic or two of where I cut the tri tip for the seam.
 
Here is a Pic of left to right burners with the crossover tube. The left side is hotter. If your parents have this type the searing will be a little hotter on the left.
20211015_215600.webp
 
Cut on the seam pre sear.
20210611_175015.webp
 
20210611_193949.jpg
 
20211024_191650.webp
20211024_191854.webp
 
I ended up doing the Tri Tip on my parents electric smoker then seared it on their gasser. It turned out really good and everyone liked it. I also did three 4 pound chuck roasts but I did them on my traeger and drove them to their house and let them rest while I did the tri tip.
 
Back
Top